Boiler Efficiency Evaluation & Tuning, Implementation for Converting Boilers, Fuel Boiler Conversion, Mumbai, India
Boiler Efficiency Evaluation & Tuning, Implementation for Converting Boilers, Fuel Boiler Conversion, Mumbai, India
Tank dimensions Water Oil
-Length 124 120
-Width 298 120
-Height 124 90
Volume of tank 4.582048 1.296
Calibration factor 36.952 14.4
 
Drop in level 53 8.1
Actual consumption during test 1958.46 116.64
Evaporation Ratio

16.79 

lt. of water / lt. of oil
 

18.25 

kg of water / kg of oil
Heat balance across boiler
Average feed water temp. 74.00  °C
Average Steam Pressure 10.00  kg/cm2
Feed water temperature at economizer inlet 40.00  °C
 
Enthalpy of saturated steam at above pressure 664  kcal / kg
Enthalpy of water at boiling 185.6  kcal / kg
 
Enthalpy of steam at the above evaporation ratio

409.00 

 
 
Quantity of saturated steam

62.16 

%
Quantity of water carry over

37.84 

%
 
Actual Efficiency of boiler on dry saturated steam

67.03 

%
Heat loss in hot water

7.72 

%
 
Heat gain in economiser 6.21  %
Heat loss in feed water tank 3.45  %
 
Useful heat available to process 72.90  %

Comments : Though the boiler efficiency of 84% by indirect method shows that the performance of boiler is very good.   However, due to the design of non-IBR boilers, there is lot of heat wastage from water carry over and wet steam.  This is normally not accounted in the plant efficiency evaluations.  The contribution of economiser diminishes as the feed water temperature increases due to condensate recovery.  That is the reason why Useful heat to process is as low as 72.90% against the Indirect boiler efficiency of 84.40%  

Tuning of boiler Boiler efficiency test for both the boilers was carried out during the Energy Audit study. Major findings  of the test before are as follows:

PARTICULAR 850 kg/hr boiler 600 kg/hr boiler
Average fuel consumption 40 lt./hr 31 lt./hr
Net Heat available to process 74.80% 75.07%
Efficiency of steam generation
Heat loss in moisture separator
WHR in Economizer Loss in the FW tank
67 %
7.72%
8.2%
1.5%
69.37%
7.44%
6.50%
Nil
Boiler Tuning: During he Energy Audit study, boiler tuning was done,  the tuning of boiler has led to following results:
PARTICULARS 850 kg/hr 600 kg/hr
  Before Tuning After Tuning Before Tuning After Tuning
CO2 % 13 13 8 11
Temperature at boiler outlet 450°C 370°C 450 °C 370°C
Temperature at Economiser outlet 210°C 180°C 270 °C 210°C
Net useful heat available to process 74.80 % 78.97 % 60.0 % 75 %

This tuning of boiler is expected to reduce the fuel bill by around 5 to 10% depending upon the operating hours of the boilers. This tuning is done by reducing the fuel quantity and optimizing the air to fuel ratio. Normally, the plant operators change the settings arbitrarily. It is, therefore, necessary to do this exercise periodically.

The minimum monetary saving expected is Rs. 1.5 Lacs per annum.

WASTE HEAT RECOVERY FROM THERMOPAC STACK :

The Thermic fluid heater burner has a capacity of 1 Lac kCal/hr (corresponding to 10 kg/hr LPG firing.). Flue gas temperature is 300°C & flow rate is 302 M3/hr.

It is therefore proposed to tap heat content in flue gases by installing Waste Heat Steam Generator in the stack.

WASTE HEAT RECOVERY ECONOMICS:
1. Qty of gases through vent (V2) = 302 M3/hr
2. Temp. of gases through vent (V2) = 300°C
3. Gases can be safely cooled to 150°C ----------
4. Waste Heat recovery potential = 302 X 0.25 X (300-150) X 1.2
   = 13600 kcal/hr
Steam qty.(@3 kg/cm2 ) that can be generated through the available Waste Heat.
  = 13600/(650-30)
  = 22 kg/hr
Saving on low pressure steam = 22 X 0.60 X 8,000
@ Rs. 0.6/kg steam cost. = Rs. 1,05,000 per year
Total saving out of proposed system    
Total = Rs. 1,05,000/Year
Investment Proposed = Rs. 60,000
Pay Back Period = 7 Months

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
Designed & Hosted by : MID   Promoted by : GID